VACUUM FURNACES TECHNICAL CONTENT

Diffusion Bonding in Vacuum Furnaces: A Critical Aerospace Application:

Vacuum heat-treating furnaces are used in a wide range of applications, one of the most critical being the heat treatment of components for aerospace applications. These applications typically allow for metals to be heated to extremely high temperatures with little or no gas contamination. One vacuum furnace application is diffusion bonding. This article, which originally appeared in Heat Treat Today’s March 2019 Aerospace print edition, provides a basic explanation of diffusion bonding of an aerospace part carried out in vacuum furnace.


Diffusion bonding is a solid-state joining process. Parts are bonded or welded together without the use of a bonding filler material between the metals. Instead, the bonding process is based on the atomic diffusion of elements between the metals where the materials meet. It is a very effective process for creating a strong bond between dissimilar materials. The process has been used extensively in the aerospace industry for joining materials and shapes to create components or shapes that could otherwise not be made joined to geometric complexity, e.g., multiple-finned channels and honeycomb structures. Today, many diffusion bonding operations are performed in vacuum furnaces.

The diffusion bonding process relies on four process parameters:

  • ultra-low vacuum levels
  • temperature
  • pressure, and
  • time.

All four of these parameters are critical for the successful exchange of atoms between metal surfaces.

Typical Materials Used in Diffusion Bonding

Some metals are more successfully diffusion bonded than others. In the aerospace industry, titanium (Ti) is excellent and widely used. This is due, in large part, to its high specific strength, good erosion resistance, and favorable high-temperature properties. Titanium is 30% stronger than steel yet 40% lighter, and while it is 60% heavier than aluminum (Al), it is twice as strong. Moreover, titanium can be alloyed with other elements such as aluminum, manganese (Mn), iron (Fe), molybdenum (Mo), and other elements to further enhance its considerable strength, particularly at high temperatures. This high-temperature strength is especially useful in the aerospace industry for the containment of combusting rocket engine fuels. Titanium is also valued for its anti-corrosion properties.

In the aerospace industry, titanium is used in manufacturing the structural components of wings as well as skins for hydraulics systems in aircraft, various components of aircraft engines and the cabins of spacecraft, where its qualities are irreplaceable.

Keys to Successful Diffusion Bonding

As mentioned above, diffusion bonding most frequently takes place in a vacuum furnace and is heavily dependent on time, temperature, vacuum levels, and pressure. Let’s take a look at a couple of these parameters as they relate to the vacuum furnace.

Vacuum:

For a successful diffusion bonding process, an ultra-high vacuum level is important. In order for the successful diffusion of atoms to take place between the mating surfaces of the two materials, the surfaces must be microscopically clean. Ultra-high vacuum levels help to prepare the surfaces for a successful bond. The removal of hydrogen is critically important. Any trace of hydrogen could thwart a successful bond. Ultra-high vacuum levels help ensure the elimination of hydrogen from the work area. Also critical is the removal of nitrogen, which, if not eliminated can form nitrides which also can prevent a successful bond. Ultra-high vacuum levels also help remove other trace gases and vapors including oxygen and water, all of which are detrimental to a successful diffusion bond.

Temperature:

Once the desired ultra-high vacuum levels have been achieved – one indication that the surfaces are cleaned and ready for the bonding process to continue – heat is applied to the furnace. The exact temperature of the diffusion bonding process is dependent on the materials being bonded.

Pressure:

Once heat has begun to be applied to the load, argon is typically added to the chamber. Argon, a heavy, inert gas, is typically used in diffusion bonding processes as opposed to nitrogen, because, as stated above, there is a risk of nitride formations if nitrogen is used. Argon avoids this risk. As argon is introduced into the work chamber, and as heat is being applied, the pressure inside the furnace begins to build to the desired level. The exact pressure is dependent on the materials being bonded and other parameters. It is important to note that argon is added during the heat up cycle and not before or after. This is not done before the heat cycle because the expanding of argon might cause an over-pressure situation resulting in the wasting of argon when the pressure is released. Argon is not introduced into a fully heated furnace because the introduction of cold gases into the furnace would cause thermal cycling (temperature drops) as well as thermal shock to internal furnace parts. A controlled introduction of argon into the furnace is a critical part of the diffusion bonding process.

.
Time:

The final parameter is time. Again, depending on the materials being bonded, the diffusion bonding cycle time can vary significantly.

Diffusion Bonding of Turbine Blades

Diffusion bonding is often used to produce turbine blades by bonding the two lateral elements of the blade with another titanium shape in the middle. The uncovered surfaces of the internal shape are covered with a layer of ceramic dust. Once the diffusion bonding treatment has been completed, the parts are subjected to super-plastic forming (SPF) where pressure is used to blow out the sides and raise the edges of the intermediary metal. The part is then given the twist typical of an airfoil blade through hot pressing in a die.

Lighter Parts & Increased Fuel Efficiency

Aerospace companies that use blades produced with this method have found a significant improvement in engine performance. Hollow core fan blades produced with SPF/DB processes are lighter and stronger than traditional fan blades. The result is a 5% reduction in fuel consumption. And reduced fuel consumption is something that makes everybody happy.

About the Author: Guido Locatelli is the TAV VACUUM FURNACES SPA Deputy General Manager and Furnacare, Inc. President, an expert in mechanics, materials, and new technologies in the field of vacuum furnaces. Since 1984, TAV VACUUM FURNACES has been producing customized industrial vacuum furnaces worldwide. In 2015, TAV established its American company group Furnacare, Inc., in Spartanburg, South Carolina. This article originally appeared in Heat Treat Today’s March 2019 Aerospace print edition and is published here with the author’s permission.

Diffusion Bonding in Vacuum Furnaces: A Critical Aerospace Application: Read More »

10 Heat Treat Tips: Vacuum Furnaces

Heat Treat 2019 is coming, and one of the great benefits of gathering with a community of heat treaters is the opportunity to challenge old habits and look at new ways of doing things. Heat Treat Today’s 101 Heat Treat Tips is another opportunity to learn the tips, tricks, and hacks shared by some of the industry’s foremost experts. The inaugural list of 101 Heat Treat Tips was published in the FNA 2018 Special Print EditionThis special edition is available in a digital format here.

Today's Technical Tuesday features 10 Tips -- all from the Vacuum Furnaces category and all supplied by the same equipment manufacturer.

Heat Treat Today is compiling the 2019 101 Heat Treat Tips list for the fall issue to be distributed at Heat Treat 2019, the biennial show from the ASM Heat Treating Society to be held in Detroit, Michigan, October 14-17, 2019. If you have a heat treat-related tip that would benefit your industry colleagues, you can submit your tip(s) to doug@heattreattoday.com or editor@heattreattoday.com.

 


Heat Treat Tip #24

Dirt In, Dirt Out!

Parts going into the furnace should be as clean as possible. Avoid placing parts in the furnace that contain foreign object debris (FOD). FOD on work surfaces going into the furnace will contaminate the furnace and the parts themselves. Dirty work in, dirty work out. FOD comes in many forms. Most common: oil, grease, sand in castings or grit blasting operations, and metal chips that generally originate from the manufacturing process before the parts are heat treated. It could also be FOD from the shipping process such as wood or plastic containers used to ship the parts.


Heat Treat Tip #26

Solenoid valves could be the problem if helium detection fails.
Solenoid valves could be the problem if helium detection fails.

When a Helium Leak Detector Doesn't Help

If an air leak cannot be found with a helium mass spectrometer, take apart the gas backfill or partial pressure solenoid valves to ensure they are clean. A small piece of debris can cause a valve to leak a process gas into the furnace that will not be found with a leak detector. Debris is often found in the valve seats when piping to the valve was disturbed in some way such as new piping or repair that stirs up contaminants in the line.


Heat Treat Tip #46

O2 Analyzer Helps Ensure Gas Purity

In addition to monitoring dewpoint at the farthest location from the gas source in your heat treat facility, an oxygen analyzer is also recommended as an additional tool for monitoring gas purity. Generally, the analyzers used to measure dew point drift low over time. One may think they have a very low dew point gas, however, it could be the dew point analyzer is beginning to fail. Quarterly checks of the dew point analyzer's accuracy should be taken; some OEMs recommend replacing the sensors annually. Oxygen analyzers provide a more stable reading over a period of time and build redundancy in confirming gas purity when coupled with the dew point analyzer.


Heat Treat Tip #48

Seal Threaded Connections

SWAK from Swagelok is a great thread sealing option. (photo source: LinkedIn)
SWAK from Swagelok is a great thread sealing option. (photo source: LinkedIn)

Ensure threaded connections have adequate sealing protection on them to prevent air leaks through the threads where applicable. Wipe off excess sealant once the connection is made.

  1. SWAK from Swagelok is excellent
  2. Apply to the male threads only, not on any other surface as it could contaminate the system the component is being installed on.
  3. Excess SWAK can be removed with a solvent such as acetone
  4. Finger tight first, then tighten with a wrench
  5. After the sealant is dry (recommend 24hrs by manufacturer) do not loosen as this could break the seal once cured.

Heat Treat Tip #61

Start With the Obvious

When a problem arises with the furnace, always start the troubleshooting process with the last item that was worked on. Start with the obvious; don't look for a needle in the haystack. For example, if the furnace will not pump into high vacuum and maintenance was just performed on the furnace with the pneumatic pressure valves being shut to perform that maintenance operation, the pneumatic valve to the main poppet valve on the diffusion pump may not have been re-opened, causing the diffusion pump main poppet valve to not open.


Heat Treat Tip #74

Make Sure Your Gas Meets Spec

Ensure each delivery of process gas is accompanied by a certification identifying purity, oxygen content, and dew point. For example, nitrogen should be 99.998% pure, 10 ppm oxygen max, and a dewpoint no higher than -89°F. With contaminated gas or gas that does not meet the criteria above, parts processed in the furnace and subjected to the partial pressure of the gas or quenched with the gas may also become contaminated, typically in form of oxidation and/or decarburization. Generally varying purity is not a concern, however, the specific purity of the gas required needs to be conveyed to the gas supplier and a certification supporting the gas type you ordered was delivered. An accompanying certification by the gas supplier goes a long way in audits and other disputes.


 

Heat Treat Tip #76

Specification Checklist for Vacuum Furnace Purchase

If you're planning on purchasing a new vacuum furnace, create a technical specification for the manufacturer(s) that clearly outlines the performance, functions, and accessories required on the furnace. The specifications should be reviewed by multiple departments including but not limited to engineering, quality, production, and management.

  1. List of department sign-offs required (engineering, production, maintenance, quality)
  2. Applicable documents required (i.e., AMS2750E, AMS2769)
  3. List of parameters to be recorded (temperature, pressure, flow rate, etc.)
  4. List of required alarms
  5. Physical location of furnace and associated components such as control system and surge tank
  6. Units of measurement (°F or °C, torr or Pascals, minutes or hours)
  7. How many process gases and what type
  8. Cooling rate requirements (This will help decide what quench pressure design furnace is required, for example, 2 bar or 10 bar.)
  9. How many work thermocouples are required
  10. What pre-testing verification is required for final acceptance. For example, thermal uniformity survey temperature points and tolerances, vacuum pump downtime and levels, leak up requirements, quench tests, process validation tests.

Wipe both door flanges and O-ring every time.
Wipe both door flanges and O-ring every time.

Heat Treat Tip #84

Clean the Door—Every Time!

Wipe down the front door O-ring and both flanges every time before the door is closed to ensure there is no debris on the O-ring or flange. Over time, the debris will damage the O-ring and pit the flange causing sealing issues.

 


Heat Treat Tip #91

Include Maintenance Team in New Vacuum Purchase Process

Include the maintenance manager in any furnace purchase decision. The manager and team are the ones tasked with troubleshooting, repair, and preventative maintenance. The maintenance manager will make sure the furnace has clear access for maintenance and replacement of major components including vacuum pumps, cooling motor, hot zone, and heat exchanger. The longer it takes to repair the furnace, the more downtime and lost revenue because the furnace is not running.


Heat Treat Tip #94

A properly greased O-ring will ensure a solid, leak-free seal.
A properly greased O-ring will ensure a solid, leak-free seal.

Inspect Replacement O-Rings

When replacing an O-ring, be sure the new O-ring is clean and undamaged (free of cuts, nicks, tears, or gouges) and that the splice joint is solid and true. Use a conservative amount of vacuum grease on the O-ring to ensure a tight sealing furnace. Not too much grease is needed. Rule of thumb: a light gloss or sheen, but no build-up.

 

 

 

All of today's tips were submitted by Solar Manufacturing.


If you have a heat treat-related tip that would benefit your industry colleagues, you can submit your tip(s) to doug@heattreattoday.com or editor@heattreattoday.com

 

10 Heat Treat Tips: Vacuum Furnaces Read More »

Heat Treat Tips: Make and Stick to a Clear Preventative Maintenance Program

During the day-to-day operation of heat treat departments, many habits are formed and procedures followed that sometimes are done simply because that’s the way they’ve always been done. One of the great benefits of having a community of heat treaters is to challenge those habits and look at new ways of doing things. Heat Treat Todays 101 Heat Treat Tips, tips and tricks that come from some of the industry’s foremost experts, were initially published in the FNA 2018 Special Print Edition, as a way to make the benefits of that community available to as many people as possible. This special edition is available in a digital format here.

Today, we offer one of the tips published under the Vacuum Furnace category. 


Vacuum Furnace

Heat Treat Tips #3

Make and Stick to a Clear Preventative Maintenance Program

Make sure a preventative maintenance schedule is clearly defined and adhered to. Most modern furnace control systems include diagnostics to assist in determining when certain components of the equipment require maintenance. Use these tools to prevent downtime and avoid wasting unnecessary maintenance.

  1. Change pump oil regularly: roughing, pump, boosters, and holding.
  2. Check hot zone for wear, loose, or missing hardware; verify element to ground resistance is greater than 10 ohms, vacuum out loose debris (monthly).
  3. Check water chemistry and adequate flow to and from the furnace (weekly).
  4. Check front door O-ring integrity, make sure there is no damage and that the ring is not flat; light grease as needed.
  5. Bubble check process gas lines for potential leaks.
  6. Check motor belts.
  7. Grease the main valve (monthly).

 

This tip was submitted by Solar Manufacturing.

Heat Treat Tips: Make and Stick to a Clear Preventative Maintenance Program Read More »

Common Sense Guidelines for Loading Parts in Vacuum Furnaces

 

Source: 

 

From minuscule medical implants to massive aerospace engine parts, vacuum furnaces process components that come in a variety of shapes and sizes. The challenge that faces a furnace operator is to load parts in such a way as to maximize efficiency (important) but also achieve desired metallurgical properties and minimize distortion (more important).

Understanding that loading options generally follow common sense rules can help with the puzzle of load arrangements, spacing parts properly, accommodating geometric irregularities, and loading orientation. This Technical Tuesday feature examines everything to consider about loading parts into a vacuum furnace — from the size and orientation of a workload to the “final spacing . . . [as] dictated by concerns for heating, soaking, flow (of partial pressure or backfill gases), the type and volume of quench media (e.g. oil, gas) and gross load weight.”

 

Table 1 – Common Furnace Workload Sizes

Table 2 – Typical Part Spacing Requirements

 

 

Read more: “Loading of Parts in Vacuum Furnaces”

Photo credit/caption: Vac Aero International / Typical Vertical Furnace Loading Configuration

Common Sense Guidelines for Loading Parts in Vacuum Furnaces Read More »

Hot Zone Insulation Materials Critical in Preventing Heat Loss

 

 

Source: Solar Atmospheres of Western PA

 

With electricity costs increasing, heat treat facilities are looking for ways to harness energy and minimize heat loss through a variety of insulating methods and applications. Heat Treat Today‘s Technical Tuesday feature comes from Reál J. Fradette of Solar Atmospheres Inc of Souderton, PA (with Nicholas R. Cordisco of Solar Manufacturing Inc. contributing), analyzing the different types of furnace hot zone insulation materials with the following points taken into consideration:

A) Hot Zone Designs

  • All-Metal Designs
  • Ceramic Fiber Included Designs
  • Graphite Type Insulated Hot Zones

B) Defining Hot Zone Losses For Different Hot Zone Configurations

  • Calculating Power Losses For A Given Size Furnace
  • Effect Of Hot Zone Losses On Heating Rates and Peak Power

C) Effect on Power Losses With Various Insulation Layers and Thicknesses

  • Projecting Relative Losses Versus Felt Thicknesses

D) Equating Insulation Designs To Actual Power Usage

  • Projecting Cycle Costs For Different Areas Of Operation
  • Impact of Hot Zone Type on Total Cycle Cost

E) Summary And Conclusions

An excerpt:

The heating rate of a load will dictate the total energy required to heat that load at that heating rate. Heating as fast as possible is not often the best solution to the application.

 

Read more: “Understanding Power Losses In Vacuum Furnaces”

Hot Zone Insulation Materials Critical in Preventing Heat Loss Read More »

Cooling the Vacuum Furnace: 5 Tips for Prevention, Maintenance

 

 

Source: TAV: The Vacuum Furnaces Blog

 

Andrew Alborghetti of TAV Vacuum Furnaces

It’s frustrating enough for furnace operators to encounter downtime due to failure or faulty equipment, but more so when it can be avoided adhering to basic maintenance procedures and adopting habits of diligence and quick thinking.

Andrew Alborghetti of TAV Vacuum Furnaces offers “5 tips for preventing faults caused by the process water in the cooling system [of a vacuum furnace or by] the use of unsuitable equipment.” In addition, he suggests steps to take when an emergency develops.

In a nutshell,

  1. Maintain specific purity standards of the process water.
  2. Prevent dangerous enrichment by maintaining valves.
  3. Keep an eye on your process water temperature.
  4. Avoid damage from external cold temperatures.
  5. Consider investing in a  closed circuit adiabatic water cooling system.

An excerpt:

“For the vacuum furnace to meet the considerable need for water it must have sufficient capacity (tub or tank) to quickly transfer heat from the furnace and from the load. The capacity of the tank determines the size of the system for cooling the water contained in it. Of course, the bigger the tank, the smaller the water cooling system it contains. When there are numerous furnaces, the size of the tank is calculated based on averaged values for behavior in the respective heat cycles.” ~ TAV Vacuum Furnaces

Click below for more on the 5 tips as well as steps you can take should your shop face an emergency such as a power outage that affects the water cooling system

 

Read more: “The Furnace Cooling System: 5 Tips to Avoid Damage”

 

Photo credit: TAV Vacuum Furnaces Blog

Cooling the Vacuum Furnace: 5 Tips for Prevention, Maintenance Read More »

Binder Removal in Vacuum Sintering

 

Source: TAV: The Vacuum Furnaces Blog

 

Andrea Alborghetti, Technical Manager of TAV Vacuum Furnaces

Heat Treat Today previously posted Parts 1 and 2 of this series on vacuum sintering. Part 1 focused on the two processing steps of debinding and sintering. Part 2 addressed primarily the vacuum sintering furnace itself. This installment analyzes the process and variables involved with binder removal.

Andrea Alborghetti, technical manager of TAV Vacuum Furnaces and contributor to the company’s blog, provides an analysis of burning vs capturing binders, addressing advantages as well as problems that may arise and how to execute control in the process, as in this example:

“One thing that is worth clarifying is that the flames usually seen on the outlet of kilns that use combustible gases (hydrogen, for example) as the process gas, were not originally designed to burn the binder disassociation residues to reduce emissions to the legal limits. Rather, it is solely for disposing of the emitted hydrogen safely, thus avoiding hazardous, potentially explosive atmospheric concentrations being created outside of the kiln.”

Read more for further analysis of binder removal, including discerning the type of residue found with your process: “Perfect Vacuum Sintering Step by Step #3”

Binder Removal in Vacuum Sintering Read More »

Coatings Reduce Surface Temps, Firing Times for Kilns and Furnaces Alike

 

ThomasNet.com

 

Today’s best of the web features a video demonstration from the Crafts Center of North Carolina State University (NCUS), which recently released the results of the trial application of high-temperature ceramic coatings to the linings of kilns used at the center.

Cone 10 Gas Reduction Car Kiln at North Carolina State University Crafts Center

Jennifer Siegel Clay, studio manager at NCUS Crafts Center, summarizes the process of lining two kilns with coatings from ITC Coatings, which produces high-temperature ceramic coatings for kilns, forges, furnaces, ovens and metal equipment, first developed in 1980 in Alliance, Ohio, by Feriz Delkic, a ceramic engineer who was running his own pottery business at the time. ITC Coatings provides solutions to problems faced by industries with heat treatment processes such as steel, power generation, and petrochemical, as well as ceramic artists and home hobbyists all over the world.

The first kiln, a 50 cubic foot Cone 10 gas reduction car kiln was coated with ITC 100HT. The outside surface temp was reduced by 30+ dF and the firing time was reduced by 1 hour (28 hour firing). The second kiln, a Barrel Raku kiln, was coated with ITC 296A. The outside surface temperature was reduced by 50+ degrees F, firing time was reduced by half, and gas consumption was reduced by greater than one third. Siegel Clay refers to it as “armor for your kilns.”

 

Read more: “ITC Technical Ceramic Coatings Announces Data Results from North Carolina State University Product Installation” and “Kiln Application Results: Gas Consumption Reduced by More Than 30%”

Watch the video:

Coatings Reduce Surface Temps, Firing Times for Kilns and Furnaces Alike Read More »

A Heat Treater’s Primer on Getter Materials

 

Source: VAC AERO International

 

A common dilemma for operators of vacuum systems is to protect the integrity and maintain the life expectancy of components when the presence of unwanted gaseous contaminates threatens to destroy the sensitive materials in the processing environment. Getter materials are the MVPs that step up to the plate to protect work in a low-pressure vacuum environment.

Table 1 [1] Getter Capacity of Common Materials
The folks at VAC AERO International have provided a primer on getter materials which answers the heat treater’s questions, such as:

  • What is a getter?
  • What are the properties of getter materials?
  • What materials are best as getters for most heat-treating applications? What about for more sophisticated applications?
  • What are non-evaporative getters, and what role do they play?

“For heat treaters, getters are often considered a last resort to help keep parts ‘bright and clean’. In point of fact, they play an important role in successful vacuum processing of many highly sophisticated products and materials. As a result, we need to do a better job of understanding their role; how and where they can help.”

 

Photo Credit and caption: Titanium Discs used as a Getter Material in Brazing of Oxidation Sensitive Components – (Photograph Courtesy of California Brazing, Newark, CA)

A Heat Treater’s Primer on Getter Materials Read More »

Matching Gases with Vacuum Heat Treatment Operations

 

Source: VAC AERO International

 

Relative Gas Supply Cost Notes: [a] Based on a minimum usage of 2830 cubic meters (100,000 cubic feet) per month. [b] All gases compared to nitrogen whose relative cost is unity. [c] Based on liquid supply.
Heat treaters use a variety of gases with vacuum furnaces during the processing cycle in partial pressure operation, for backfilling to atmospheric pressure at the end of the processing cycle, and for cooling/quenching. In this article, VAC AERO describes the most common of these gases — (in order of frequency of use) nitrogen, argon, hydrogen and helium — as well as other common gases such as various hydrocarbons and ammonia (for vacuum carburizing/carbonitriding) and specialty gases such as neon (for certain electronics applications), and analyzes their uses and value in various vacuum heat treating processes. In addition, their relative cost per 100,000 cubic feet, the liquid properties and physical properties of common backfill gases, and the conversion between common pressure and vacuum units are explored.

Read more: “Types of Backfill, Partial Pressure, and Cooling Gases for Vacuum Heat Treatment”

 

Matching Gases with Vacuum Heat Treatment Operations Read More »