Diffusion Bonding in Vacuum Furnaces: A Critical Aerospace Application:

Vacuum heat-treating furnaces are used in a wide range of applications, one of the most critical being the heat treatment of components for aerospace applications. These applications typically allow for metals to be heated to extremely high temperatures with little or no gas contamination. One vacuum furnace application is diffusion bonding. This article, which originally appeared in Heat Treat Today’s March 2019 Aerospace print edition, provides a basic explanation of diffusion bonding of an aerospace part carried out in vacuum furnace.


Diffusion bonding is a solid-state joining process. Parts are bonded or welded together without the use of a bonding filler material between the metals. Instead, the bonding process is based on the atomic diffusion of elements between the metals where the materials meet. It is a very effective process for creating a strong bond between dissimilar materials. The process has been used extensively in the aerospace industry for joining materials and shapes to create components or shapes that could otherwise not be made joined to geometric complexity, e.g., multiple-finned channels and honeycomb structures. Today, many diffusion bonding operations are performed in vacuum furnaces.

The diffusion bonding process relies on four process parameters:

  • ultra-low vacuum levels
  • temperature
  • pressure, and
  • time.

All four of these parameters are critical for the successful exchange of atoms between metal surfaces.

Typical Materials Used in Diffusion Bonding

Some metals are more successfully diffusion bonded than others. In the aerospace industry, titanium (Ti) is excellent and widely used. This is due, in large part, to its high specific strength, good erosion resistance, and favorable high-temperature properties. Titanium is 30% stronger than steel yet 40% lighter, and while it is 60% heavier than aluminum (Al), it is twice as strong. Moreover, titanium can be alloyed with other elements such as aluminum, manganese (Mn), iron (Fe), molybdenum (Mo), and other elements to further enhance its considerable strength, particularly at high temperatures. This high-temperature strength is especially useful in the aerospace industry for the containment of combusting rocket engine fuels. Titanium is also valued for its anti-corrosion properties.

In the aerospace industry, titanium is used in manufacturing the structural components of wings as well as skins for hydraulics systems in aircraft, various components of aircraft engines and the cabins of spacecraft, where its qualities are irreplaceable.

Keys to Successful Diffusion Bonding

As mentioned above, diffusion bonding most frequently takes place in a vacuum furnace and is heavily dependent on time, temperature, vacuum levels, and pressure. Let’s take a look at a couple of these parameters as they relate to the vacuum furnace.

Vacuum:

For a successful diffusion bonding process, an ultra-high vacuum level is important. In order for the successful diffusion of atoms to take place between the mating surfaces of the two materials, the surfaces must be microscopically clean. Ultra-high vacuum levels help to prepare the surfaces for a successful bond. The removal of hydrogen is critically important. Any trace of hydrogen could thwart a successful bond. Ultra-high vacuum levels help ensure the elimination of hydrogen from the work area. Also critical is the removal of nitrogen, which, if not eliminated can form nitrides which also can prevent a successful bond. Ultra-high vacuum levels also help remove other trace gases and vapors including oxygen and water, all of which are detrimental to a successful diffusion bond.

Temperature:

Once the desired ultra-high vacuum levels have been achieved – one indication that the surfaces are cleaned and ready for the bonding process to continue – heat is applied to the furnace. The exact temperature of the diffusion bonding process is dependent on the materials being bonded.

Pressure:

Once heat has begun to be applied to the load, argon is typically added to the chamber. Argon, a heavy, inert gas, is typically used in diffusion bonding processes as opposed to nitrogen, because, as stated above, there is a risk of nitride formations if nitrogen is used. Argon avoids this risk. As argon is introduced into the work chamber, and as heat is being applied, the pressure inside the furnace begins to build to the desired level. The exact pressure is dependent on the materials being bonded and other parameters. It is important to note that argon is added during the heat up cycle and not before or after. This is not done before the heat cycle because the expanding of argon might cause an over-pressure situation resulting in the wasting of argon when the pressure is released. Argon is not introduced into a fully heated furnace because the introduction of cold gases into the furnace would cause thermal cycling (temperature drops) as well as thermal shock to internal furnace parts. A controlled introduction of argon into the furnace is a critical part of the diffusion bonding process.

.
Time:

The final parameter is time. Again, depending on the materials being bonded, the diffusion bonding cycle time can vary significantly.

Diffusion Bonding of Turbine Blades

Diffusion bonding is often used to produce turbine blades by bonding the two lateral elements of the blade with another titanium shape in the middle. The uncovered surfaces of the internal shape are covered with a layer of ceramic dust. Once the diffusion bonding treatment has been completed, the parts are subjected to super-plastic forming (SPF) where pressure is used to blow out the sides and raise the edges of the intermediary metal. The part is then given the twist typical of an airfoil blade through hot pressing in a die.

Lighter Parts & Increased Fuel Efficiency

Aerospace companies that use blades produced with this method have found a significant improvement in engine performance. Hollow core fan blades produced with SPF/DB processes are lighter and stronger than traditional fan blades. The result is a 5% reduction in fuel consumption. And reduced fuel consumption is something that makes everybody happy.

About the Author: Guido Locatelli is the TAV VACUUM FURNACES SPA Deputy General Manager and Furnacare, Inc. President, an expert in mechanics, materials, and new technologies in the field of vacuum furnaces. Since 1984, TAV VACUUM FURNACES has been producing customized industrial vacuum furnaces worldwide. In 2015, TAV established its American company group Furnacare, Inc., in Spartanburg, South Carolina. This article originally appeared in Heat Treat Today’s March 2019 Aerospace print edition and is published here with the author’s permission.

Diffusion Bonding in Vacuum Furnaces: A Critical Aerospace Application: Read More »

Ohio Manufacturer Receives Upgrades to Plant’s Heat Treatment Equipment

An Ohio manufacturer of processing equipment recently received heat treating upgrades to its facility from a heat treat controls system manufacturer, also in Ohio.

Milacron LLC  partnered with Super Systems, Inc., based in Cincinnati, Ohio, to make major upgrades to the heat treating assets at its plastics machinery facility in Mt. Orab, Ohio.

Included in the scope of work were new control cabinets, atmosphere flow panels, SCADA software, and a new ammonia dissociator. The work has been completed for this project.

“We are very happy we chose Super Systems…  The quality and workmanship set them apart from others in the industry,” said Jeff Bissantz, project engineer, who led the Milacron team.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ohio Manufacturer Receives Upgrades to Plant’s Heat Treatment Equipment Read More »

U.S. Army Research Lab Invests to Develop Powerful Metal Powder 3D Printer

The Combat Capabilities Development Command Army Research Laboratory, also known as ARL, recently awarded a 3D engineering and manufacturing company a $15 million contract to create a metal 3D printer that it intends to be the world’s largest, fastest, and most precise.

3D Systems and the National Center for Manufacturing Sciences (NCMS) were awarded funding to create this printer and will partner with ARL and the Advanced Manufacturing, Materials, and Processes (AMMP) Program to advance the leadership and innovation. This printer will impact key supply chains associated with long-range munitions, next-generation combat vehicles, helicopters, and air and missile defense capabilities.

“The Army is increasing readiness by strengthening its relationships and interoperability with business partners, like 3D Systems, who advance warfighter requirements at the best value to the taxpayer,” said Dr. Joseph South, ARL’s program manager for Science of Additive Manufacturing for Next Generation Munitions. “Up until now, powder bed laser 3D printers have been too small, too slow, and too imprecise to produce major ground combat subsystems at scale. Our goal is to tackle this issue head-on with the support of allies and partners who aid the Army in executing security cooperation activities in support of common national interests, and who help enable new capabilities for critical national security supply chains.”

According to the U.S. Army Additive Manufacturing Implementation Plan, the Army has been using additive manufacturing (AM) for two decades to refurbish worn parts and create custom tools. Once developed, the Army will leverage its manufacturing experience by placing the new large-scale systems in its depots and labs. Subsequently, 3D Systems and its partners plan to make the new 3D printer technology available to leading aerospace and defense suppliers for development of futuristic Army platforms.

 

 

U.S. Army Research Lab Invests to Develop Powerful Metal Powder 3D Printer Read More »

Refractory Supplier Celebrates Manufacturing Facility Expansion

A supplier of refractory products and services in North America recently celebrated the completion of its phase one facility expansion plan.

HarbisonWalker International (HWI) hosted a ribbon-cutting event at its manufacturing operations in White Cloud, Michigan, to celebrate completion of the first phase of an expansion that increases the floor space of the facility by 35%.  The project is part of a $9 million investment being made this year to significantly increase warehousing space along with the addition of new, advanced manufacturing and hydraulic press technologies.

Carol Jackson
President & CEO
HarbisonWalker International

“White Cloud is an extremely important facility that has been vital to our company and the community for more than four decades,” said Carol Jackson, chairman and CEO at HWI. “Historically, and especially in the past two years, the team at White Cloud has helped fuel our steel industry customers’ success by consistently delivering on their tremendous demand for the refractory products we produce here. We’re so proud of the great work our White Cloud employees do every day for our company and our customers.”

HWI’s White Cloud operations primarily produces refractory products that are utilized by the steel industry.

Refractory Supplier Celebrates Manufacturing Facility Expansion Read More »

Auto Parts Maker Purchases Hot Stamping Furnace

An international automotive corporation that designs, develops, and manufactures metal automotive components recently received a hot stamping furnace from a manufacturer of standard and custom industrial heat treat furnaces.

The Gestamp Research and Development facility, located in Auburn Hills, Michigan, added an electrically heated, four chamber hot stamping furnace built by Lindberg/MPH, an industrial thermal processor.

Bill St. Thomas
Business Development Manager Lindberg/MPH

“This Lindberg/MPH hot stamping furnace provides uniform heating for a wide variety of high-strength steels or aluminum materials prior to hot stamping or hydro-forming applications. The team at Gestamp has been incredible to work with on this project and we are proud to be their supplier,” said Bill St. Thomas, Business Development Manager.

The furnace is integrated at the Gestamp facility with a robotic transfer system and hydraulic hot stamping press. The four chambers operate independently with the top chamber designated for aluminum treatment. This type of hot stamping system allows the customer the flexibility to treat different steels simultaneously and takes up a much smaller footprint than a continuous system.

Auto Parts Maker Purchases Hot Stamping Furnace Read More »

Leaders in Heat Treat Connect via Social Media

Heat Treat Today invites you to join us on LinkedIn! In addition to our company page, we connect heat treaters in four specialized groups:

Leaders in Aerospace Heat Treat

Leaders in Automotive Heat Treat

Leaders in Medical Heat Treat

Leaders in Energy Heat Treat

These are professional-level spaces where heat treaters from industry sectors can discuss relevant issues and ideas, and Heat Treat Today will regularly provide content, keeping members current on the latest technologies, products, processes, and discussions. Join a group today!

Leaders in Heat Treat Connect via Social Media Read More »

Domestic Steel Producer & Recycler Selects New Flat Roll Mill Site

A domestic steel producer and metals recycler chose Sinton, Texas, as the site for the company’s new electric-arc-furnace (EAF) flat roll steel mill.

Steel Dynamics, Inc., a carbon steel producer which also owns Vulcan Steel Products that services the heat treat industry, recently announced its preferred choice as the Sinton location, 30 miles northwest of the port of Corpus Christi, Texas, because it is strategically located within the targeted Southwest U.S. and Mexico market regions; it’s central to the largest domestic consumption of flat roll Galvalume® and construction painted products; and it provides sufficient acreage to allow customers to locate on-site, providing steel mill volume base-loading opportunities.

Mark D. Millett
President and CEO
Steel Dynamics, Inc.

“We have been developing a flat roll steel business strategy for this region and Mexico for several years,” said Mark. D. Millett, President and Chief Executive Officer, “and the team is ready to execute.  We have extensive experience and a proven track record for successfully constructing and operating EAF steel mills and downstream value-add finishing lines.  Our planned new EAF flat roll steel mill will be the most technologically advanced facility existing today.”

 

 

 

 

 

 

Photo credit: entecfurnaces.com

Domestic Steel Producer & Recycler Selects New Flat Roll Mill Site Read More »

Safeguarding Refractory Installation: 12 Vital Steps to a Flawless Dry-Out

Dan Szynal, VP of Engineering & Technical Services, Plibrico
Dan Szynal, VP of Engineering & Technical Services, Plibrico

Installing new refractory materials is a necessary furnace maintenance practice which needs to be done periodically. But extended downtime and installation errors can be a major financial and operational headache. In this article, Dan Szynal, VP of Engineering & Technical Services, Plibrico, gives 12 factors which will ensure that the refractory installation is successful.


At 700°F, steam can exert 3,000 psi pressure.
At 700°F, steam can exert 3,000 psi pressure.

During an initial dry-out, the powerful effects of superheated steam can cause explosive, devastating consequences to freshly cured refractory material. To that end, removing moisture from castable and precast shapes is a serious pursuit. The production pressures to minimize downtime can lead to shortcuts and rushed dry-out procedures. Usually, these sidesteps have the opposite effect, quickly compounding delays and costs by causing thermal damage to the linings and potentially incurring personal injury.

Dry-outs fail due to imprecise management of water extraction from refractories. At the boiling point of water, the pressure of steam is less than 1 psi. However, at 700°F, saturated steam reaches 3,000 psi, and possesses enough energy to disintegrate the most resilient refractories. Too much heat, rapid ramp-ups, vapor lock, poor curing, and surplus water can contribute to potentially hazardous situations.

Here are the 12 preventive factors to manage for dry-out safety and success:

1. Hot spots and flame impingement. Ensure that your burner flame is centered accurately. The direction of flame in the vessel must promote equal heating of all the refractory surfaces. A flame that impinges on a single area of the surface will quickly create a hot spot, forcing an unequal expansion of water vapor in that area and resulting in thermal spalling.

Thermocouples need to be monitored at both hot and cold areas to measure temperature consistency.
Thermocouples need to be monitored at both hot and cold areas to measure temperature consistency.

2. Temperature spikes. Insulation is ill-advised. Attempting to cover green castable with an insulating blanket can lead to destructive temperature spiking when the blanket is removed, breaks, or falls off. At a wall surface temperature of only 550°F, the removal of insulation exposes the surface to an extreme temperature shift which will activate unequal steam expansion and pressure.

3. Thermocouple placement and monitoring. Pay attention to the locations and readings of your TCs. Watching only the coldest location will allow the hottest area of your vessel to heat too quickly in the dry-out schedule. Conversely, monitoring only the hottest area will allow the colder area to retain more water than specified. This will lead to failure later in the schedule or during hold periods. At 700°F, steam can exert 3,000 psi pressure.

4. Air temperature vs. surface temperature. Thermocouples should report surface temperature. Air temperatures are typically 50°F to 100°F hotter, thus misreporting schedule impact. The initial hold period is typically designed to melt burn-out fibers. That creates important permeability. If the actual load temperature is lower than specified, permeability is not created, leading to failure in the next ramp-up period.

Pre-cast refractory requires longer bake-out schedules to release all water vapor.
Pre-cast refractory requires longer bake-out schedules to release all water vapor.

5. Field vs. precast dry-out schedule. A field dry-out schedule is specified for single-sided heating. It precipitates a dual water migration, first (stage 1) towards the heat as the path of least resistance, but then reversing course (stage 2) and moving away from the heat, escaping towards the furnace shell. Field dry-outs are faster schedules than precast, where the pieces are heated from all sides simultaneously. The precast water migrates to the center of the piece, and that takes longer to escape. By misapplying the faster field dry-out to precast, there is a greater risk of water retention, which will ultimately lead to spalling, even at temperatures of 550°F or less.

6. Venting and air circulation. Proper venting is required to rid the furnace of water vapor during dry-out. Without vents and free air circulation, the steam is forced to exit via the furnace shell, which takes longer than the schedule would provide. Water will be retained closer to the shell side, increasing the likelihood for disintegration as temperature and steam pressure rise.

7. Surface coating. An impermeable coating on the refractory surface will prevent the stage 1 escape of water. Slowly, this water will be forced to move to its second exit, the furnace shell. This delay prepares the still-saturated refractory for failure at the next heat ramp-up.

8. Clear obstruction from weep holes. As stage 2 water migration occurs, it will escape to the furnace shell. There should be adequate weep hole capacity, cleared of obstructions which will allow the water to exit the furnace shell. These provide a release valve for buildup of steam pressure. Thermocouples need to be monitored at both hot and cold areas to measure temperature consistency. Pre-cast refractory requires longer bake-out schedules to release all water vapor.

9. Cold weather curing. In the curing process, simple hydrates form needle-like morphology. These structures promote permeability, and water/steam can more easily migrate through the refractory to escape. Curing in below-freezing temperatures alters the hydrates to be less permeable, thus trapping the water, even during dry-out and creating an inherent risk. As well, cold weather curing slows the required strengthening process, leading to a weaker refractory and likely spall. We have had a thermal operator tell us about a below-freezing cure that went badly: The water in the castable actually froze in place. When the dry-out was initiated, the castable melted and fell to the floor, where it subsequently cured and dried.

10. Cutting short cure time. Recommended dry-out schedules always assume a 24-hour equivalent curing time at moderate temperatures. By cutting short the cure time, water is retained, and strength is reduced. For example, a conventional castable requires 24 hours cure time; high cement/low moisture castable needs at least 16 hours. Adherence to product cure time specifications ensures optimum strength and a successful dry-out.

11. Free water removal without consideration. The goal of curing and dry-out is to create permeability in the refractory at lower temperatures (300°F) to enable water to escape. By quickly ramping up dry-out temperatures for the sake of time, permeability is diminished. At higher temperatures, (+500°F) steam pressure rises aggressively. Again, refractory composition drives curing and dry-out schedules, and as a rule, the faster temperatures rise beyond specification, the higher the risk of failure.

Pre-cast shapes spall at 550°F.
Pre-cast shapes spall at 550°F.

12. Refractory strength as a function of water content. A simple 1% excess of water will reduce refractory strength by as much as 20%. Overwatering by 1.5% cuts strength 25% to 40%. The implications are profound: the refractory will not withstand the steam pressures in dry-out, and worse yet, there is more water that must be extracted. A successful dry-out can be jeopardized by the slightest variance in water composition.

Conclusion

Meticulous care in refractory installation is the foundation to successful furnace operation. While no one looks forward to non-productive downtime, close adherence to product specifications, cure times, and dry-out schedules will ensure a more profitable return to operations. Managing the water issues in refractory composition is job one.

Safeguarding Refractory Installation: 12 Vital Steps to a Flawless Dry-Out Read More »

A.M. Manufacturing Best Practices Webinar Opens Registration

An educational presentation aimed at helping organizations as they begin mass-producing parts in their AM production facilities has opened registration for the webinar, September 11, 2019, 2 p.m.

Todd Wenzel
Todd Wenzel

The presentation, hosted by Bluestreak/Bright A.M., is titled, “Additive Manufacturing Production Work Order & Process Management Best Practices” and will address the additive manufacturing process from the completion of the design phase including, best practices for work order entry, through shipping the completed parts.

In addition, participants will hear from Todd Wenzel, presenter, about lessons learned after working with AM production facilities (in the U.S. and other countries) for the past several years. Every AM production facility has its own unique problem areas, production issues, and headache-causing events once a work order has been received for producing additively manufactured parts. Additionally, some part-builds come with stringent specification (and compliance) requirements that must be adhered to.

As products are being designed, made and used in new ways, Additive Manufacturing production facilities are all working towards continuous improvement in each operational step within their predefined AM production processes, as well as more complete documentation (especially in aerospace and medical applications).  Time will also be spent discussing real-time job tracking, and individual part tracking as parts that were created on the same build plate with different serial numbers may progress throughout the production facility processing steps in different ways and in different processing order, in some cases.

Topics to be covered include:

  • Work order instructions, media attachments, real-time tracking
  • Build-Plate management and serialization (multiple parts with different serial numbers printed on the same Build-plate)
  • Nonconformances/Advanced Dispositioning
  • Part Production Tracking: Sequential, out-of-sequence, multiple possible routes
  • Managing outside vendor processing
  • Tracking machine time, labor time, material usage (virgin, 1x, 2x)
  • Collecting and requiring quality data
  • Connecting/viewing specifications, operating instructions, and QMS documents directly from the production floor
  • Using specifications to automatically qualify equipment, operators, or vendors, to prevent improper processing of the parts.
  • Connected/complete documentation (makes auditors very happy)
  • The Best Way to have a complete AM processing audit trail for each part produced with all associated documents linked together
  • Defining and generating new work order “packages” for repeat part builds

The presentation includes content applicable to Additive Manufacturing Applications, Facilities & Operations, Final Part Production, Part Inspection and Certification, Post Processing, Process Monitoring, Control and Qualification, Quality and Standards, Process Control and Quality Management tied directly to individual operators on the production floor.

For more information and to register, click here.

A.M. Manufacturing Best Practices Webinar Opens Registration Read More »

Vacuum Furnace Manufacturer Adds Advanced Firing Capabilities

A high-temperature vacuum and controlled atmosphere furnace manufacturer recently invested in new equipment for advanced firing capabilities.

Centorr Vacuum Industries recently announced it has added new furnace capabilities to its Applied Technology Center for customer use for process proofing, toll work, and process development runs.

The new furnace is based on Centorr’s successful Super VII platform and will join two smaller System VII furnaces, an induction melting furnace, and a continuous belt furnace already in use.

This newly updated 2nd Generation Super VII design comes with several innovative features to allow the processing of a wide variety of metals, hard metals, ceramics, and carbon/graphite composites. The furnace can be used for low temperature degassing, heat treating, annealing, brazing, and sintering of a variety of materials.

 

Vacuum Furnace Manufacturer Adds Advanced Firing Capabilities Read More »