power supply

10 Steps To Troubleshoot Your Induction System

OC

Nikola Tesla said, “If you want to find the secrets of the universe, think in terms of energy, frequency, and vibration.” These three components are evident in getting to know the inner workings of an induction system. When it comes to troubleshooting such a system at in-house heat treat departments, this 10 step guide will help heat treat operators understand the secrets of induction and solve common problems that may arise.

This original content article was first written by Alberto Ramirez, engineer of Power Supply and Automation at Contour Hardening, Inc. and an honoree from Heat Treat Today’s 40 Under 40 Class of 2021, for Heat Treat Today's May 2023 Sustainable Heat Treat Technologies print edition.


Alberto Ramirez
Power Supply and Automation Engineer
Contour Hardening, Inc.

Contact us with your Reader Feedback!

Metals can be heated by the process of electromagnetic induction, whereby an alternative magnetic field near the surface of a metallic (or electrically conductive) workpiece induces eddy current (and thus heat) within the workpiece. Induction systems can be complex systems that aim to heat treat specific parts or sections of a mechanical component; depending on the degree of complexity of the part to be treated, it will be the challenge of a professional to detect any problem.

1. Familiarize Yourself with the Process

Figure 1. Induction hardening process
Source: Contour Hardening, Inc.

The induction process involves many characteristics such as: position of the piece within the induction coil, load positions, cooling positions, cycle times, applied electric power, and others. It is important that the professional can identify the failure and the particular situation at the moment in which it is occurring.

On some occasions, the failures are not evident and therefore it is essential to analyze the part that has been treated. This analysis can be key to understanding situations such as poor depth due to electrical power or decrease in output frequency, among other possible scenarios.

In addition to the analysis of the piece, it is vital to inspect the “crime scene,” since many of the induction systems — given the nature of the process and the danger involved in handling high electrical potentials — are usually highly automated and the work stations are difficult for staff to access. A good work strategy consists of carefully observing the general conditions of the equipment to determine where the problem will begin to be solved.

2. Identify Main Components and Certain Security Mechanisms of Your Induction System

Understanding the interrelationship of the system is important to comprehend which element performs a certain action, as well as the communication channels between them. Once this knowledge is generated, a failure can be associated with a particular component. Induction systems are usually made up of the elements in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Induction system components
Source: Contour Hardening, Inc.

As we mentioned before, the process involves high electrical potentials, and for this reason, the nature of the power supplies involves power electronic devices such as electrical capacitors, which store energy. Therefore, it is important to electrically discharge the system before beginning to inspect a piece of equipment.

3. Have the Necessary Tools Ready To Carry Out a Good Analysis of the Problem

Figure 3. Capacitors
Source: Contour Hardening, Inc.

Like any technical problem, the use of a mechanical tool is essential when carrying out some type of project, but for the diagnosis of failure in induction equipment it is important to have:

  • Oscilloscope
  • Function generator
  • Ammeter
  • Digital and analog multimeter
  • High voltage probes

Without these elements it is exceedingly difficult to reach a reliable diagnosis, and the possibility of finding the fault is minimal. Therefore, having these meters in good condition and above all, calibrated, gives a clearer perspective of the problem.

4. Verify that the Process Sensors, Power Monitors, and Induction Coils Are Working Properly

There are different meters that collect information about the process. This information can mostly be viewed through the HMI (human machine interface). On many occasions, a good way to begin to understand the problem is by collecting the information on the process. If these meters do not work correctly, they can lead you to wrong conclusions.

Verify the energy meters are working correctly, as well as your input and output signals.

Induction coils are a key element in the induction process since, according to their geometry, they generate the appropriate magnetic fields to achieve the expected metallurgical results. If there are water leaks or the electrical transmission elements are loose or dirty, it could be the root cause of the problem. It is important to start troubleshooting once this circuit is ruled out.

Figure 4. Energy parameters example
Source: Contour Hardening, Inc.

5. Carry Out Studies of Constant Energy in Your Substation To Identify Possible Problems in Your Energy Supply, Including Critical Times

Electrical energy is the main source in an induction process, power supplies transform and potentiate this resource to create electronic fields strong enough to generate heat in the piece.

Therefore, it is important to find evidence that rules out failures of the electrical system that the induction system is a part of. In the same way, understanding how our electrical system behaves can help us generate behavior patterns that can determine the solution at specific times when it may arise.

6. Document Your Work Methodically and Take One Step at a Time

Induction systems can be very intimidating if you have not had previous experience, and, like any element or situation, it is important to logically approach the problem by analyzing the failure mode, identifying the main parts that interact at that specific moment. From there, document and take small steps, one at a time. If you don’t, it is very likely you will lose all the work you have done, and the situation will get worse.

Figure 5. Before and after of an arc at the transmission line
Source: Contour Hardening, Inc.

If the moves are unsuccessful, you can always return to your starting point and try another approach. The idea is that the failure mode remains the same no matter what moves you make until the problem is resolved. In this way you will have the failure contained, otherwise you could be damaging other elements without realizing it.

It is very important to understand that the processes are sequences that precede and proceed new events. If you understand the process and solve a problem, but now have a new failure, it is important to analyze if this failure is the continuation of the process. If so, it is possible that you find yourself in a case where an event is triggering a series of failures. Therefore, a more in-depth analysis must be carried out. The idea to generate is to get to the root cause and mitigate the risk.

7. Try Any Possibility Related to the Process Regardless of Whether the Relationship Between It and the Problem Is Not Direct

Logical thinking can solve most of the technical failures of a system. For exceptional failures, however, it is necessary to use your imagination and exhaust all possible resources, since the smallest area of interest or the least thoughtful place can be the key to solving a problem.

8. Get To Know Your Power Supplies

One of the key factors in any induction equipment is its power supplies. Power supplies are equipment that do not require such arduous maintenance compared to other systems in the industry, but if the minimum maintenance conditions are not present, they can generate high losses for the organization.

Figure 6. Flow diagram of the energy process at the power supply
Source: Contour Hardening, Inc.

In cases where the problem is the power supplies, it is vital that the same methodical process previously described is followed. Understanding how the energy transformation process works will give you an advantage, as will knowing the elements that compose them or the type of technology used in the rectification process, in the inversion (solid state or electron tubes) and in the resonant circuit. Generally, power supplies follow the transformation in Figure 6.

9. Identify the Critical Parts of Your Induction Equipment and Prepare an Inventory

Figure 7. Coil damage
Contour Hardening, Inc.

Usually, the elements that belong to the power supplies are difficult to obtain depending on the age of your equipment. With the recent microchip crisis in the market, control and automation elements have very long delivery times or the prices are very high. Therefore, it is vital that there is a list of critical parts and an inventory of these.

In addition to the elements described, induction coils are usually very characteristic and important elements in the induction process. These coils are complex elements that have been designed exclusively for the piece, so their manufacture can take several weeks, and the necessary precautions must be taken to maintain a constant maintenance movement.

10. Perform Preventative Measurements to the System To Generate a Pattern of Behavior

Figure 8. Possible examples of measurements
Contour Hardening, Inc.

When the system is working in optimal conditions, generate a measurement plan which allows you to generate information on specific points within the system. Once a new failure occurs again you can compare the measurements of failure against those of good performance. Some examples of measurements can be:

  • Temperature
  • Voltage
  • Current
  • Resistance and capacitance
  • Waveforms

Summary

An orderly and documented work methodology, a good spare parts catalog, and the necessary work tools can be key elements to understand a problem and, more importantly, to solve it effectively.

It is vital that professionals are in continuous training in order to decrease downtime due to failures in induction systems. Training related to metallurgical processes would be a good way to complement your resolution skills by being able to interpret the characteristics of induction systems with the elements that compose it.

 

References

Valery Rudnev and George Totten, ed., ASM Handbook Volume 4C: Induction Heating and Heat Treatment, (Materials Park, OH: ASM International Heat Treating Society, 2014), 581- 583.

 

About the Author: Alberto C. Ramirez graduated from the National Technical Institute of Mexico as a mechatronics engineer. He earned his master’s degree in information technology administration from Monterrey Institute of Technology. With more than eight years of experience in power supplies, project management, maintenance, and automation, he currently works as a Power Supply and Automation Engineer at Contour Indianapolis. Alberto began his career at the Contour subsidiary in Mexico and due to his dedication, he is part of the staff in the United States. He is also an honoree from Heat Treat Today's 40 Under 40 Class of 2021.

For more information:

Contact Alberto at Contact Alberto at aramirez@contourhardening.com.

 

 


Find heat treating products and services when you search on Heat Treat Buyers Guide.com


 

10 Steps To Troubleshoot Your Induction System Read More »

Upfront Planning: What To Expect with Induction Design and Fabrication

OC

Induction heat treating: no harsh chemicals, gases, or even CO2 emissions. But to get there, heat treaters should first understand how to plan for an induction design and fabrication project upfront. Consider these five important factors before you dive into induction.

This Technical Tuesday article was composed by John Chesna, general manager at Induction Tooling, Inc. and honoree in Heat Treat Today's 40 Under 40Class of 2022. It appears in Heat Treat Today's May 2023 Sustainable Heat Treat Technologies print edition.


Introduction

John Chesna
General Manager at Induction Tooling
Source: Induction Tooling, Inc.

There are many less than obvious factors to consider when preparing and planning for induction. So where to start? There are five important factors that manufacturers with in-house heat treat operations should understand in order to successfully prepare an induction heating project and design.

Contact us with your Reader Feedback!

But first, what is induction heating? Induction heat treating is the process in which a high frequency conductor (induction tool) induces currents (eddy currents) into an electrically conductive workpiece. Without ever touching the work-piece, the current generated and the resistance causes heating. Ever since its proven usefulness around the time of World War II, induction has been chosen as the go-to heat treatment for a variety of applications across many industries including agricultural, medical, and transportation. Now, it seems that most industries have taken advantage of induction heat treating, and its popularity will likely only continue to increase with the push for the use of “clean” and “green” energy.

#1 Plan for Inductor Wear

One of the most important factors to an induction project is realizing the inductor/ coil is a wear item. It can be highly engineered, hand fabricated, machined, or even 3D printed. Yet, in the overall process, it is still a wear item: an item that will eventually require replacement or repair. The inductor is exposed to the worst of the elements during the induction process and can fail from standard use, accidents, or unforeseen circumstances. Inductor designers are constantly being challenged to create tools that will last longer, require less maintenance, or run more cycles. All of those can be achieved, but the inductor will eventually require replacing and that is not a bad thing!

A properly serviced and maintained inductor will ensure quality parts are being produced. As the inductor wears, the efficacy degrades, leading to undesirable results. Repair of the inductor will correct this issue and ensure the parameters required for the desired heat treat pattern are restored. Depending on production needs, a good principle is to have more than one inductor on hand so that while one is being repaired the spare inductor can remain on the machine to keep up with manufacturing demand. Planning for this is important for the project’s timing and budget.

#2 Types of Inductor Designs

Determining a specific inductor design will be necessary to properly heat parts. The inductor creates the magnetic field in the workpiece, and typically the inductor is shaped to couple closely where heat treatment of the part is desired. Additionally, if quenching is required for the heating application, this function will be considered in the inductor’s design. The inductor’s design must deliver the electrical energy and quench medium to the workpiece while allowing accessibility for material handling purposes. For this reason, inductors take on many different designs.

Common inductor designs include:

  • Pancake: used for heating flat surfaces
  • Single turn or multi-turn: commonly shown as copper tubing wrapped around cylindrically around the workpiece
  • Hairpin: typically, a simple back and forth loop used to heat long lengths internally or externally on the workpiece
  • Split return: used to focus the energy in particular areas of the workpiece
  • MIQ (machined integral quench) paddle: the most commonly used design for scanning applications

#3 Power and Frequency

Know the power supply and/or work-head power and frequency. Depending on the composition of the part that requires processing, the power and frequency of the equipment will help estimate the depth of the pattern that can be achieved, as well as help determine how successful the part will be for induction heating. Irregularly shaped geometries with points, holes, or sharp edges sometimes cause difficulty establishing eddy currents where the induction pattern is desired. Some parts, after review, are good candidates for induction heat treatment but cannot be processed with the existing power supply and/or work-head setup.

If an inductor is being built to mount to existing induction equipment, it is important to know the scope of parts that are currently being processed or expected to be processed on the machine. The electrical circuit of the power supply, work-head, and inductor must load match to the part. If a variety of parts are being run then multiple styles of inductors may exist or will be required to be used. Different designs of inductors, e.g., single-turn, multi-turn, or split return used on the machine will change the transformer effect and capacitor requirements of the system. Availability to tune the system capacitance and inductance becomes vitally important for operation. Please note that adjusting capacitance can be dangerous and should only be done by a trained technician. Newer power supplies function differently than older models, yet load tuning needs to be considered.

#4 Part Details

A detailed pre-induction print is needed. The print should list the material as well as the desired heat treatment pattern to determine the inductor design. As the print specifies the pattern, it should also provide limits. Inductors are then typically designed to the shape of the part. The inductor may require an integrated quench, electrically insulating protective coating, locators, or additional assembly fixturing depending on the part’s size. An inductor built for one part may be used or tried on a similar part. However, the same results cannot be expected to render on the part for which it was not designed. If the manufacturer knows that a family of parts will be run, the full scope should be presented to inductor designers for consideration before the build.

#5 Material Handler

Ideally an inductor supplier would be contacted to develop the induction heating process for a part; then, that information should be shared with the material handling designer. That would be the ideal, but that’s not the way it usually happens. Sometimes, a machine is built to process a part that no longer is in use, so the machine is now being retrofitted to process different parts. The design of a new inductor is needed to accommodate this existing machine which may create size constraints to the inductor’s design.

The contact style, how the inductor mounts to the work-head, will need to be determined. There are a variety of commonly used power supplies and work-heads available from OEMs in the market. As each OEM keeps their contacts standard to their equipment, there is no singular standard footprint in the market. Once the contact style has been determined, the inductor can be designed for maximum power delivery efficiency. How the part and inductor are presented to each other is important. The centerline distance, a measurement from where the inductor mounts to where the part will be processed, needs to be known. The centerline determines the required length of the inductor and indirectly how much room is available for the inductor’s design.

Conclusion

Due to the variety of factors, no two projects are ever the same. Induction heating is an exciting technology, and I encourage everyone to learn more about it.

 

About the Author: John Chesna is the general manager of Induction Tooling, Inc. and has been involved with the induction heat treating industry for over 8 years. He is a graduate of the University of Akron with a Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering Technology. His responsibilities include overseeing day-to-day operations including the design, manufacturing, and testing of induction heat treating inductors. Additionally, John was a recipient of Heat Treat Today's 40 Under 40 award in 2022.

Contact John at jchesna@inductiontooling.com.


Find heat treating products and services when you search on Heat Treat Buyers Guide.com


 

Upfront Planning: What To Expect with Induction Design and Fabrication Read More »

Skip to content